Although an earlier CD added five previously unissued tracks to the original LP Gerry Mulligan Meets Ben Webster, this Verve Master Edition two-CD set adds just about everything else recorded during the two sessions that produced the original record, and also features 20-bit sound.
Even though Gerry Mulligan was outspoken against issuing material omitted from his original recordings, it is a treat to hear how the songs evolved in the studio. Webster and Mulligan seem mutually inspired throughout the sessions, and strong performances by pianist Jimmy Rowles, bassist Leroy Vinnegar, and drummer Mel Lewis are of considerable help. The music is presented in the order in which it was recorded, with each CD devoted to a separate session. In both cases it is clear that the initial takes of music from the Ellington songbook ("In a Mellotone" and "Chelsea Bridge") are more focused than the follow-up versions. They only needed one try to nail "What Is This Thing Called Love?" (also left off the LP), in an understated setting that shows off their beautiful interplay. Their barely disguised reworking of "I Got Rhythm," called "Who's Got Rhythm," was likely an effortless performance, though Webster seems to briefly laugh in the middle of his solo. Webster's swinging "Fajista" opens the second date, followed by two takes of Mulligan's beautiful ballad "Tell Me When." Webster's "Blues in B-Flat" is another fine swinger inexplicably left off the LP, and Rowles kicks off the oldie "Sunday" with a brief stride piano introduction (something Webster played himself but rarely in a recording studio). Fans on a budget can probably make due with the earlier CD reissue but serious fans of Mulligan and/or Webster should invest in this very rewarding set instead.
- Ben Webster - tenor saxophone
- Gerry Mulligan - baritone saxophone
- Jimmie Rowles - piano
- Leroy Vinnegar - bass
- Mel Lewis - drums
Disc 1:
01. In A Mellow Tone (CD master take) (7:21)
02. In A Mellow Tone (alternative take) (7:23)
03. What Is This Thing Called Love? (CD master take) (7:29)
04. Chelsea Bridge (LP master take) (7:24)
05. Chelsea Bridge (alternative take) (7:36)
06. Go Home (breakdown - rehersal and false start) (2:17)
07. Go Home (LP master take with insert as issued) (10:03)
08. Who's Got Rhythm? (LP master take) (7:51)
09. For Bessie (CD master take) (6:01)
10. Go Home (end of unedited-3) (1:44)
11. Go Home (unedited insert) (1:30)
Disc 2:
01. Fajista (false start) (1:35)
02. Fajista (alternative take) (6:21)
03. Fajista (discussion and rehersal) (1:37)
04. Fajista (CD master take) (5:58)
05. Tell Me When (alternative take) (5:03)
06. Tell Me When (LP master take) (5:30)
07. Blues In B Flat (breakdown - discussion - false start) (2:46)
08. Blues In B Flat (alternative take) (8:39)
09. Blues In B Flat (CD master take) (7:24)
10. The Cat Walk (rehersal and discussion - false start and discussion - brеakdown) (3:26)
11. The Cat Walk (alternative take) (5:45)
12. The Cat Walk (warmup - breakdown - breakdown) (2:13)
13. The Cat Walk (LP master take) (6:19)
14. Sunday (false start - alternative take) (5:33)
15. Sunday (LP master take) (7:22)
